Page 1 of 2

So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Fri Dec 06, 2019 8:47 am
by pigfender
A while ago - really quite a fair while ago now - I promised Keith that I’d produce some videos on how the whole Novel in a Day thing is run, including how Scrivener and Scapple are used throughout the process.

I’ve scribbled some notes on what to cover, but wanted to give you lot the chance to feed in too. I’ll be covering topics in three broad areas: story development / event planning, taking part / writing a chapter, and book production.

So, over to you...
Are there any parts of the process you’d especially like to see?

Are there any questions you’d like answered?

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Fri Dec 06, 2019 4:55 pm
by Jaysen
pigfender wrote:Are there any parts of the process you’d especially like to see?

I'd like to see the liquor selection process... what factors are evaluated? what criteria are used for brand selection

pigfender wrote:Are there any questions you’d like answered?

how do we get more vic-k channeled into the overall process?

Seriously, you do such a great job with this, I almost don't want to see how you do it. I feel like it's seeing how the sausage is made..

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Sat Dec 07, 2019 2:41 am
by gr
I don’t know if this is helpful but I can report how I have learned what I’ve learned about the process. The stuff you have posted on your site about plotting taught me a great deal about how you think about genre and use scapple while plotting out an idea. Between that and actually looking at how the Scriv projects are laid out is what has given me what sense I have of how the Niadustrial light and magic is produced. Not to mention participating, of course.

As for its probable interest for someone like me (given all the above): There is all kinds of admirable cleverness in the Scriv project set up and compile that I note but have not really interrogated. For someone like me who is already wound up in it, I guess that would be the most revealing part — how that project gets used in the course or the process and some of the clever high points of how it is set up to facilitate that.

I do hope in the videos we will finally get a glimpse of the smoke and mirrors. I know they’re there. Don’t try to deny it.

gr

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 4:40 pm
by pigfender
Jaysen wrote:I'd like to see the liquor selection process... what factors are evaluated? what criteria are used for brand selection

It's a two-part evaluation methodolgy that balances price and quality scores into a classic cost/benefit anaysis to identify the most economically advantageous product.

Price is featured in three individual tests. The first is an affordability threshold which sets an upper limit ('A') for the beverage. Any liquor priced greater than this predetermined level is automatically excluded. The second is a lower threshold limit ('B') below which it is not expected that -- whatever the claims to quality espoused by brand stakeholders (manufacturers, commercial partners, resellsers, or customer credentials (often described as 'reviews')) -- the cost could be considered sufficient to develop a liquor solution suitable.

So, if the price C is >= B and <= A it remains in consideration for the third cost test which occurs after quality assessment.

Quality is scored independently of cost. Scores out of 10 are created as objectively as possible using the following scale: 0 = complete fail / no redeeming qualities, 1-4 = unacceptably deficient, 5-6 = modest deficiencies against expected standards, 7 = meets expectations, 8-9 = over acheives against expectations, 10 = no further improvement would be of value.

The following quality areas are scored and the scores aggregated on a weighted average to produce a score out of 100%: taste (40%), appearance (20%), smell (20%), brand prestige (7.5%), tactile experience (7.5%), time between refills (5%). Scores are generated based on previously experience as much as possible, but failing that, multiple evaluators will be invited to assess and discuss scores in a score assurance moderation session.

If a product scores 0-4 on any quality criteria post-moderation it is automatically excluded. The quality scores of the remaining products are then recombined with the price score. Contrary to modern combination methodologies, I prefer a simple Quality / Price formula to produce a single comparable [Benefits Points per £] score for each liquor which can then be directly compared to identify a winner.

Jaysen wrote:how do we get more vic-k channeled into the overall process?

Invite him to join discussions, include him in converstations, and provide regular (re-)assurances to him that his contributions are adding value and appreciated.

Jaysen wrote:Seriously, you do such a great job with this, I almost don't want to see how you do it. I feel like it's seeing how the sausage is made..

I love sausages. So much so that Mrs PF once arranged for me to visit a butcher's shop to learn to make them. I still love sausages because it's only the sausages that you already know are nasty that you don't want to see made. Good sausages are made of good ingredients and watching the butcher make them (and maybe having a go yourself) only makes you enjoy them all the more.

gr wrote:There is all kinds of admirable cleverness in the Scriv project set up and compile that I note but have not really interrogated. For someone like me who is already wound up in it, I guess that would be the most revealing part — how that project gets used in the course or the process and some of the clever high points of how it is set up to facilitate that.

Okay, so more of the process-saving aspects like project replacements, dynamic todo lists, and embedded scapple maps ("mapples"?)?

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 7:05 pm
by Camy
My problem is--grizzle grizzle--a bleedin' expensive now obsolete Mac that won't run Scrivener 3, ergo I can't open your project files and extract their undoubted wisdom. Poot.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 7:22 pm
by Jaysen
pigfender wrote:time between refills (5%).

Seems to me that to SHORT a time between refills will lead to .. unreliable results. For some of us that may show up an a condition known as "hangover from hell". This is why I'm not allowed to drink unsupervised UNLESS a NiaD is involved.

Having typed that... it feel appropriately dirty.

pigfender wrote:
Jaysen wrote:Seriously, you do such a great job with this, I almost don't want to see how you do it. I feel like it's seeing how the sausage is made..


I love sausages. So much so that Mrs PF once arranged for me to visit a butcher's shop to learn to make them. I still love sausages because it's only the sausages that you already know are nasty that you don't want to see made. Good sausages are made of good ingredients and watching the butcher make them (and maybe having a go yourself) only makes you enjoy them all the more.

Your experience may have a different starting point. My experience started with "that one there... will you deliver to Smith's for ... processing?" Then following them over to Smiths. Keep in mind, I've done the process with other critters so it's not a weak stomach thing. It just ... ruined it. Still like me some sausage, bacon and ham, but I'm not so keen on it as I used to be.

I'm a bit frightened of this point from grrrrrrr (emphasis added)
gr wrote:The stuff you have posted on your site about plotting taught me a great deal about how you think about genre and use scapple while plotting out an idea.

I have enough voices running around in my cranium. I don't really need you and vick-k in there.

:P

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 2:02 am
by gr
Jaysen wrote:Having typed that... it feel appropriately dirty.

I feel I should point out at this juncture that Jaysen just referred to itself by the non-human pronoun ‘it’.*

Jaysen wrote:I'm a bit frightened of this point from grrrrrrr

I will be using this quote as my lead-in for all future forum posts.

-grr

* To think that I have been mispersoning/misphyluming Jaysen all this time by using person pronouns.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 2:27 pm
by Jaysen
gr wrote:
Jaysen wrote:Having typed that... it feel appropriately dirty.

I feel I should point out at this juncture that Jaysen just referred to itself by the non-human pronoun ‘it’.*

Jaysen wrote:I'm a bit frightened of this point from grrrrrrr

I will be using this quote as my lead-in for all future forum posts.

-grr

* To think that I have been mispersoning/misphyluming Jaysen all this time by using person pronouns.

I fully endorse all aspects of grrrrr's analysis.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2019 3:32 pm
by pigfender
Camy wrote:My problem is--grizzle grizzle--a bleedin' expensive now obsolete Mac that won't run Scrivener 3, ergo I can't open your project files and extract their undoubted wisdom. Poot.

Hmmm - sorry about that. I'll get a v2 compliant version of the last two made NiaD project files and upload them.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2019 11:40 am
by Camy
pigfender wrote:
Camy wrote:My problem is--grizzle grizzle--a bleedin' expensive now obsolete Mac that won't run Scrivener 3, ergo I can't open your project files and extract their undoubted wisdom. Poot.

Hmmm - sorry about that. I'll get a v2 compliant version of the last two made NiaD project files and upload them.

That would be really kind, but please don't rush. I am patience personified.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2019 2:00 pm
by pigfender
The Mac v2 / Win v1 compatible project files have now been uploaded to the relevant book pages!

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Sat Dec 14, 2019 2:23 pm
by Camy
pigfender wrote:The Mac v2 / Win v1 compatible project files have now been uploaded to the relevant book pages!

Thankee! :D
I'd say you are a Baa Lamb, but I wouldn't want to insult the bestest Pigfender I know.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 11:42 am
by Velviit
Hello everyone.

I’m just interested in getting my part of the book to you.
I quite like the fact that I don’t have to worry about how it all works after that point.

I think someone said ‘smoke and mirrors’
That’s good enough for me.

I’m looking forward to being part of the process 91/2 kind of cool.

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Sun Mar 29, 2020 7:54 pm
by Camy
Velviit wrote:I quite like the fact that I don’t have to worry about how it all works after that point.

I think someone said ‘smoke and mirrors’
That’s good enough for me.

Smoke, mirrors and a very, very frazzled Pigfender. :P

Re: So... how does Novel-in-a-Day work?

Posted: Mon Mar 30, 2020 1:14 pm
by Jaysen
Camy wrote:
Velviit wrote:I quite like the fact that I don’t have to worry about how it all works after that point.

I think someone said ‘smoke and mirrors’
That’s good enough for me.

Smoke, mirrors and a very, very frazzled Pigfender. :P

Day after NiaD we call him "Mr Bacon" because he's fried.

Ha! I make me laugh.

Piggy has been quite open about the mess of his little project. You can also DL all the old scriv files he uses to develop the chapters. Much of the "smoke" is just piggy working hard to come up with outline, chapter briefs, and then managing the NiaD event. The "mirrors" are the various folks that support him in unsung roles. The size of NiaD at this point requires that he has a few helpers throughout. Not sure who they are, but Mrs Fender is definitely back there helping him stay motivated (I suspect there is a rolling pin involved).