Locked Inspector doesn't navigate consistently with its editor

JJ
JJSlote
Posts: 660
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2010 5:44 pm
Platform: Windows
Location: NY, USA

Sun Jun 26, 2016 12:23 am Post

Greetings

To my understanding, locking the inspector is designed to tie the inspector to a particular editor pane, so as to describe the document shown in that editor even after focus is claimed by, and navigation takes place in, the opposite editor.

But sometimes a locked inspector remains set on a particular document without regard to navigation in its associated editor. By observation, a locked inspector will respond to navigation in its editor only when that editor has focus. Otherwise it may linger on a third document that isn't among those then being edited.

For example: Inspector unlocked. Outline view in the left editor. The right editor has focus. We navigate to a doc in the binder and lock the inspector. Back arrow in the right editor: inspector focus correctly follows. Click on a document in the left editor's outline view. Right editor follows, but inspector remains set to the back-arrowed document, not active in either editor.

Similarly, with the inspector locked to the right editor, let's give the left editor the focus. Now let's click on the right editor's back arrow. The right editor positions to the desired doc, but the inspector remains fixed on the prior one. With a second click on the back arrow the inspector does follow; that's because the right editor took the focus with the first click.

Same applies to Scrivener Links. They'll navigate in the unfocused editor, but an inspector locked to that editor won't move along.

I've also definitely had a case where the locked inspector navigates with the non-associated editor, but I can't reproduce it at the moment.

Rgds -- Jerome

db
dbc183c7
Posts: 144
Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 12:59 am
Platform: Windows

Thu Dec 08, 2016 8:14 pm Post

Salutations ... and thanks, Jerome.

For me, now, I still often have to go through multiple verifications/steps to ensure that the Inspector I'm looking at is the Inspector I want.

I have noticed other inconsistencies with how the right-hand Editor works; thought this might be another. I haven't experienced a similar vagueness trying to lock a left Editor, but I then I try to lock that one far less often than the right, the latter being of more use to me.
(Principally due the propensity of editor outlines to scroll uselessly as I drag a to-be-linked document across them from the Binder, even moderately quickly.)

I mostly wrote off my difficulties getting the correct Inspector 'up' and stuck in place to my incomplete understanding of the functionality ... and of Scrivener in general.

g

JJ
JJSlote
Posts: 660
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2010 5:44 pm
Platform: Windows
Location: NY, USA

Thu Dec 08, 2016 9:51 pm Post

Hi DBC -- Thanks for picking up on this forlorn thread.

This is the manual's depiction of locked inspector behavior.
18.10 Locking the Inspector
When using two editor splits,you can lock the Inspector to the current editor so that when
the other editor in the split view receives focus, the Inspector does not change contents
but instead continues to display information about the document in the editor you locked
it to. Click on the icon of the padlock in the top right corner of the Inspector to toggle
this state.

Does not fit with the user experience described above, which hasn't changed in version 1.9.7, released since then.

Rgds -- Jerome